Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries
Overview
After her breakup, Cheryl inherits an Amish gift shop in Sugarcreek, hoping for a fresh start. But eerie stuffed animals, a sudden kidnapping, and buried town rivalries quickly shatter the calm. Forced to team up with Naomi and Levi, Cheryl plunges into a dangerous hunt through hidden secrets and old grudges, racing to uncover the truth before it’s too late.
Episodes
-
1
The Buggy Before the Horse
An unseen trespasser challenges the community’s trust and kindness, forcing Cheryl to hurry and safeguard Sugarcreek’s peace before the Thanksgivi...
-
2
A Season of Secrets
When an Amish boy disappears without a trace, Cheryl uncovers a trail of hidden messages and buried secrets that lead straight into the heart of Sugar...
-
3
O Little Town of Sugarcreek
Cheryl’s quiet holiday is shattered when a string of Christmas thefts hits close to home and her ex unexpectedly returns. Forced to shield a naive f...
-
4
Off the Beaten Path
A mysterious bus disappears without a trace. A pair of fake FBI agents appear, stirring up trouble. As Cheryl digs for the truth, she finds her courag...
-
5
Simply Vanished
When Cheryl stumbles upon a concealed chute, it pulls her into a mystery that's been buried for decades—a cold case involving a vanished teenager. A...
-
6
Stitch in Time
When Cheryl uncovers an old, hand-stitched quilt tucked away in the attic, its hidden pocket reveals a long-buried family secret. As she follows the c...
-
7
Mason Jar Mayhem
During a routine cleanup at the community center, Cheryl stumbles upon a locked box filled with letters and trinkets from World War II. The hidden tre...
