My Two Dads
Overview
Joey and Michael, rivals from 13 years past, find themselves unexpectedly united after the death of the woman they both loved. With joint custody of her daughter, Nicole, who could belong to either man, they forego the usual paternity test. Instead, they decide to cohabitate and create a unique two-dad family dynamic. Navigating the challenges of parenthood under the scrutiny of a family court judge, the trio embarks on a humorous journey of adjustment, exploring the complexities of their unconventional arrangement while forging a bond that transcends traditional family roles.
Episodes
-
1
Pilot
In the series opener, two friends who previously had romantic feelings for the same woman come together at the reading of her will. There, they discov...
-
2
Soho's by You
Title: Soho's by You Plot: Michael is determined for the family to relocate to his uptown apartment, but the change poses challenges. Nicole will hav...
-
3
Crime and Punishment
Title: Crime and Punishment Plot: Nicole heads out for a movie night with a friend, but their plans take an unexpected turn, leading them to New Jers...
-
4
Nicole's First Date
Joey tries to prepare Nicole for her first date, giving her advice on various aspects of dating. However, he totally overlooks what she should do if h...
-
5
Friends and Lovers
Title: Friends and Lovers Plot: Nicole sets Michael up with a neighbor, initially finding the situation entertaining. However, as their relationship ...
-
6
Whose Night is it, Anyway?
Both dads have arranged dates for the same evening, leading them to choose Nicole and her friends to take care of themselves for the night.
-
7
Once a Son . . .
Joey makes a deal with his father: if he doesn’t sell any artwork at his solo exhibition, he’ll step in to help with the family plumbing business.
-
8
Sex, Judge, and Rock & Roll
Following Joey’s unsuccessful attempt to connect with a woman, Michael finds success, but his triumph is fleeting when he discovers that the woman i...
-
9
The Artful Dodger
Title: The Crafty Con Plot: Joey's attempt to defend Nicole's struggling art score leads to an unexpected outing with her teacher, resulting in less ...
-
10
Quality Time
Michael feels overwhelmed with guilt as his work commitments constantly interfere with his plans with Nicole.
-
11
'Tis the Season
Joey and Michael are excitedly looking forward to celebrating their first Christmas with Nicole. However, Nicole is avoiding the holiday spirit, as th...
-
12
The Only Child
Nicole's desire for a brother shifts to a wish for shared attention when her dads grant her request.
-
13
Joey's Mother-in-Law
Joey feels bullied, while Nicole struggles with a lack of quality time with Cory when Michael's mother pays a visit.
-
14
Nicole in Charge
Nicole insists that the racquetball championship in the loft be cancelled after Michael's intense training routine lands him in the hospital.
-
15
The Wedge
Joey’s rock-star buddy believes that Joey is dedicating too much of his time to Michael and not enough to his own life.
-
16
Advice and Consent
Cory gets some tips on how to kiss from Nicole's fathers and his older brother.
-
17
She'll Get Over It
Title: She'll Move Past It Plot: After Nicole faces disappointment from her initial modeling audition, Michael takes it upon himself to lift her spir...
-
18
Michael's Sister Comes Over and Visits
Michael's sister, whom he hasn't seen in years, comes to visit, revealing that Joey played a significant role in her choice to abandon her medical pro...
-
19
Nicole's Big Adventure
A group of friends bands together to support the fathers as they navigate the challenges of Nicole's week-long absence at camp.
-
20
My Fair Joey
Joey seeks Michael's help to refine his manners and etiquette before he meets his ideal debutante. Desperate to impress, he hopes Michael can guide hi...
-
21
The Family in Question
Title: The Family Debate Plot: After a newspaper journalist publishes a piece condemning Judge Wilbur's choice to place Nicole with her fathers, Joey...
-
22
Friends of the Family
Corey tries to set his mom up with Klawicki.
-
1
Blast from the Past
Title: Echoes of Yesterday Plot: Zach, a childhood friend of Nicole, relocates to New York and pays her a visit. Cory feels uneasy about her spending...
-
2
Who's on First?
Title: Who's on First? Plot: Nicole seeks advice from her seasoned girlfriend about the art of kissing. Meanwhile, Michael and Joey gear up for a fat...
-
3
Macho, Stupid Guy Time
While Nicole is out for the weekend, Michael and Joey decide to revive a 15-year-old wager: one of them must convince their high school’s ultimate "...
-
4
The Man in the Pink Slip
The dynamics in the Taylor/Harris home shift significantly when Michael finds himself out of work and Joey steps into a job. As they navigate this new...
-
5
Fallen Idol
When her rock and roll idol, Malcolm O'Dell, pays a visit, Nicole is completely awestruck. However, her excitement takes a turn when she discovers tha...
-
6
Story with a Twist
When 14-year-old Nicole arrives home reeking of alcohol, her Dads decide to take a dramatic approach to teach her a lesson. They orchestrate an intens...
-
7
Playing with Fire
After receiving death threats from a man she sentenced to prison, the judge finds herself in need of protection. To ensure her safety, she is assigned...
-
8
Dirty Dating
Title: Dirty Dating Plot: Nicole's frustration peaks when Joey dismisses her concerns about his relationship with a beautiful yet arrogant woman. In ...
-
9
The God of Love
Title: The Deity of Romance Plot: When Joey is discovered with a girl at his place, Nicole spills the beans to her friends, leading them to idolize J...
-
10
In Her Dreams
In a sequence of vivid dreams, Nicole explores alternate realities where her mother chose to marry either Michael or Joey, revealing how her life coul...
-
11
Together We Stand
Michael feels a rush of excitement as he starts his new job at a financial magazine alongside Joey, who is more hesitant about the whole situation. Th...
-
12
The Courtship of Nicole's Fathers
Title: The Romance of Nicole's Dads Plot: To divert her overly cautious fathers, Nicole decides to introduce them to an attractive new neighbor. As t...
-
13
Crushed
Nicole is taken aback when her best friend Shelby develops feelings for her father. As their friendship is tested, Nicole grapples with the unexpected...
-
14
Basket Case
After Nicole doesn't make the basketball team, Joey takes it upon himself to speak with her coach. He quickly discovers that she is an intensely compe...
-
15
You Love Me, Right?
Michael’s uncle arrives, and his presence isn’t exactly welcome. He has a track record of breaking promises, and now he’s making some to Nicole.
-
16
Getting Smart
Nicole makes the decision to leave her advanced English class, spurred on by her best friend Shelby. This choice comes after she accidentally hears Mi...
-
1
That's No Lady, That's My Mother
Michael is back in the dating scene, but this time he's in for a surprise—he's seeing the mother of Nicole's boyfriend! The situation quickly spiral...
-
2
Say Goodnight, Gracie
Title: Goodnight, Gracie Plot: Joey takes it upon himself to babysit his girlfriend’s daughter, Gracie, thinking it will be a simple task. However,...
-
3
Love and Learn
Nicole is in a relationship with an older guy, and when her friends find out, they insist she breaks it off. Undeterred, she sneaks out to meet him an...
-
4
You Can Count on Me
Shelby is seeing a guy whom Nicole believes is a total creep, but Shelby brushes off her concerns. Determined to show her friend the truth, Nicole arr...
-
5
Joey Gets Pinned
At his home, Joey throws a bachelor party for a friend, where he unexpectedly encounters a woman who is a wrestler. To his surprise, he finds himself ...
-
6
Story in Development
Nicole feels down as she longs for adulthood. In an effort to lift her spirits, her dads step in to remind her of the perks of being a teenager and he...
-
7
Duel
The homecoming dance is approaching at Nicole's school, and the supervising teacher approaches Joey and Michael for their input. Both boys are smitten...
-
8
Dad Patrol
Following a break-in, Joey and Michael decide to establish a personal surveillance system to ensure Nicole's safety. However, it’s Michael who becom...
-
9
Pop, the Question
Title: Pop, the Question Plot: Michael and Joey's differing approaches to parenting lead them to take a DNA test. They make a pact that the one who i...
-
10
Thanks for the Memories
Title: A Trip Down Memory Lane Plot: Joey and Michael find themselves stuck in an elevator, prompting them to reminisce about some of their most memo...
-
11
Class
Joey finds out there’s a position available for an art teacher, but he realizes he needs a college degree to qualify. Determined to pursue this oppo...
-
12
I'm Dreaming of a Holiday Episode
During the holiday season, Joey finds himself daydreaming about what life and celebrations might look like in the distant future, imagining himself mu...
-
13
Power Struggle
Irritated by the amount of time Nicole is devoting to Zach and the way they seem to ignore everyone else when they’re together, Michael and Joey dec...
-
14
Bye Bye Baby
Title: Farewell, Little One Plot: Joey is taken aback when he discovers that his girlfriend Sarah, along with her daughter Gracie, will be relocating...
-
15
Environ-mental Case
Joey ends up behind bars for participating in environmental protests, prompting Michael and Judge Wilbur to step in and secure his release.
-
16
Party, Sweet 16--See Appendix
Nicole's much-anticipated sweet sixteen celebration is thrown into turmoil when she suddenly requires an appendectomy. The joyous event she had been p...
-
17
It's My Art, and I'll Die If I Want To
Joey finally makes it into the newspaper—but in the obituary section? His obituary, mistakenly published under the name Joey Harris, declares him de...
-
18
To Thine Own Elf Be True
Joey's former high school sweetheart returns to New York, and soon finds herself drawn to Michael.
-
19
You Only Surprise the Ones You Love
As Judge Wilbur prepares to receive an honor, Joey, Michael, and Nicole believe it would be great for some of her friends and family to join the celeb...
-
20
Kind of a Drag
Nicole discovers that she’s not included in the popular group and contemplates drastic actions to elevate her social standing. Meanwhile, Joey's gir...
-
21
When You Wish ...
Nicole participates in a contest hosted by Rock TV and emerges victorious, earning the chance to enjoy a dream date centered around music. Meanwhile, ...
-
22
See You in September?
In the series finale, Joey learns that his girlfriend Sarah is planning to marry someone else. Just as the wedding is about to take place, Joey interv...
